How to Choose a Probiotic

As I stress on each of my social media channels it is important to test any potential remedy you are pursuing against the root causes is reflux. That is to say, if you do not have a sense for how a supposed treatment can help to address the underlying causes of reflux then you should be hesitant to put it in your body.

Some supposed remedies are merely symptom mitigation, as is common with many diets, herbs, and medications are. You should just be clear on what you are using and why. Additionally, take care that the remedy doesn’t mask the symptoms while worsening the underlying issues as mainstream prescription and over the counter medications do.

If you are new to this site, you should definitely start by reading my How I Cured My Silent Reflux article. It explains the underlying causes of reflux and will put the use of probiotics in the proper context for you.

All that being said, as you have read in the above linked article, you now understand how a probiotic fits in context with addressing the root causes of reflux. However, choosing a good probiotic is more involved than many realize. Don’t worry though. I have you covered as below are a few criteria you should keep in mind when choosing a probiotic.

How to choose a probiotic

  1. Probiotics are considered dietary supplements, which are not regulated by the Food and Drug Administration (FDA). As such, manufacturers do not have to prove effectiveness or safety of their products to the FDA. It is therefore on you to choose a reputable, high quality manufacturer that is tested by a third party lab
  2. To be effective, the probiotic must be alive when you take it so this is a case where you really do have to pay attention to the expiration date and storage requirements. Some need to be refrigerated while others just need to stay within a given temperature range
  3. Look for a probiotic that contains multiple strains as each strain carries different health benefits
  4. If you are purchasing your probiotic from a distributor, you should first check the website of the manufacturer and ensure there are no warnings about knock off products that you should be aware of. Due to the hype surrounding the probiotics industry you should take care to ensure you are not defrauded
  5. The quantity of probiotic matters. Take one that has enough bacteria to form colonies, which is measured in colony forming units (CFUs). You’re looking for probiotics in the 5-100 billion CFU range. If your prospective product does not even mention CFUs then it is likely not a credible supplement
  6. In healthy individuals beneficial bacteria are found in increasing abundance as you traverse the gastrointestinal tract from the mouth to the colon. Given this, it is best to find a probiotic that is enteric coated as this coating will ensure the probiotic strains are protected until they reach the target area of the gastrointestinal tract
  7. Your main source of probiotics should not be as additives to other products like teas, nutrition bars, etc. These sources are often too low a dose to be effective and they are laden with sugars which counteract the benefits of introducing probiotics by feeding and nurturing pathogenic bacteria

Here is a probiotic that I found to meet these criteria:

This is the probiotic gut reset program that I did after healing my acid reflux. Even so, I could feel the difference and improved resilience in my gut. I did 10 days of each probiotic in sequence. Be sure and ramp up your daily fiber intake to 35-50 grams daily to support the probiotics. 

Importance of Prebiotics

Ultimately, as I cover in detail in my How I Cured My Silent Reflux article, acid reflux is a digestive disorder. One can enter the reflux cycle through a number of risk factors. Poor diet can often serve as the primary or as an instigating risk factor. America, in particular is plagued with this as the typical diet is rich in processed foods, added sugars, oils, saturated fats, you name it. Even thoughts who supposedly eat ‘healthy’ are unaware of additives such as high fructose corn syrup that are in EVERYTHING from ketchup, to canned fruit, to bread and more.

What’s more, many people no longer eat much if any vegetables, fruits, legumes, nuts, seeds, whole grains. The sad part is these high fiber sources are an essential part of a healthful diet. When it comes to fiber many people are aware it can help you with regular bowel movements. That’s true, but there is much more to it than that. You see, fiber is the structural component of plant matter. It’s what allows an apple, carrot, or cabbage to hold its shape. In fact, new science as covered in this TED article are using scientific methods to carve an apple in the shape of an ear, and using specialized solutions to dissolve away everything but the fibrous structure, and then grafting human cells as a method to replace a lost ear.

That said, you may be surprised to learn that humans can’t actually digest fiber. You see, the fiber is not actually for us, it is instead an important food source for the symbiotic organisms (probiotics) that colonize our gastrointestinal tract. This is why eating high fiber sources is so important to rebuilding and maintaining healthy digestion. It is also why many people with digestive issues fail at getting their probiotics to work. They enter the body, but there is no food source for them to keep them healthy and thriving. So, to ensure your probiotic is effective you need to really ramp your fiber intake up. For me, I took this up to 35-50 grams of dietary fiber from the sources mentioned above.

Do you ever feel like all your food is out to get you? No surprise, when medical world's answer to reflux is blocking digestion (acid blockers). Wouldn't it be nice to enjoy more of the foods and drinks you love, with less of the indigestion?

I know because I was were you are for more than 15 years. That's why I created Digestion Transformation Checklist. In it, you'll find 19 actionable tips to boost your digestion, from the start to finish.

Ready for some relief? Just enter your details in below, and get the guide straight to your inbox for FREE!

Not Every Probiotic is a Good Fit

Since the advent of microbiome science there has been a proliferation of probiotics, prebiotic, synbiotic, and postbiotic products. As is typical during the hype curve with something new, there is initial excitement and optimism that it can be a cure all. Indeed, microbiome disorders (dysbiosis of the gut), have been directly linked to a wide array of disorders from acid reflux to Parkinson’s and Autism. While things like probiotics and adjusting the microbiome have shown positive improvements in diseases like Parkinson’s and autism, even more so with Fecal Microbiota Transplant (FMT) it is not yet the cure all we’d like it to be.

For digestive disorders the efficacy is significantly better, and tests have been developed such as the microbiome or gut test which can be prescribed by a functional medicine practitioner or taken at home as in the gut test kit.

Feel like you've done all the things and are just not seeing progress? I've helped a lot of people over the years that felt the same way. Perhaps an at home microbiome test can help break the cycle and provide the insights you need to move froward. With it, you can test your gut microbiome and receive actionable recommendations on how to optimize your digestive health with the BIOHM Gut Report.

I have arranged a 20% discount if you use the code THEACIDREFLUXGUY at checkout!

With the results of these tests in hand you have a much greater likelihood of finding a probiotic with the right microbiota to complement your specific deficiencies.

Alternatively, one can use the abovementioned criteria and select 2-3 potential probiotics. Give each a try over 3 days to see how it makes your body feel and discard any that do not sit well with you.

Connect With Me

Take advantage of my daily tips on InstagramYouTube, or join my mailing list to learn how hundreds, just like you, have taken control of their health!


Disclosure: This is a free website so I do advertise to cover the costs of website hosting and other services. If you find the information on this site useful, please consider making a purchase using the following links as I will earn a small commission at no cost to you.

Medical Disclaimer: The content of this site is for informational purposes only, and to give you ideas for you and your physician to research. It is not intended as individualized advice to treat, cure, mitigate or prevent any medical condition.


5 1 vote
Article Rating
The following two tabs change content below.
Don is a best selling author of 'How I Cured My Silent Reflux,' and a former acid reflux sufferer for more than 15 years. With several family members with the disease, and a medically diagnosed hiatal hernia he resigned to the fact that he would take acid blockers for the rest of his life. Dissatisfied with medical advice, he researched the root causes of acid reflux and by solving them was able to eliminate his acid reflux for good!
Notify of
Oldest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Wilson cuenca
Wilson cuenca
2 years ago

Hi Daniels I bought your book I am from Latin America and I do not speak English and the translation is difficult for me but hey I was able to read the book but I do not see in the book how the guide is to take the supplements, it says betaine hcl how many daily
digestive enzymes how many daily
apple cider vinegar how many daily
If you can take them mixed, I want guidance on how to take the supplements, please help me

2 years ago

Hi Don! I just bought your book and came across this article about probiotics. I recently stopped taking a probiotic a naturopath had recommended, because I noticed I was getting low blood sugar spells. I’ve been looking up fermented foods, and it seems like it’s hard to find a fermented food that doesn’t have dairy or isn’t spicy. Do you cover some of these things in your book? I can’t wait to start reading!

2 years ago

All kinds of GI. I have sliding hiatal hernia and gallbladder stones and pancreas cysts. Both spinchers worming fine and bravo test negative. I get bloated after eating even small amount of food and upper GI below rib cage on both sides and middle where ribs meet hurt. My throat mostly right side is inflamed and with little sore throat sometimes but lots of mucus in throat that is sticky and clear. My tongue and moth always feel like are inflamed. Do you have a saliva test for LPR? Thank you

Would love your thoughts, please comment.x